一部出乎意料优异的作品整部影片用一种粗粝的质感描述了1856年荒原中的一段隐秘爱情却在每种呈现方式中悉心打磨Abigail和Tellie的平淡独白在单簧管和大提琴的低语中流淌"Do you know what memory it is that I most cherish? It's of you turning to me with that smile you gave me once you realized that you were loved."结尾处Dyer反问Abigail你真的无法为我们彼此在做什么了呢Dyer的脸却变换成Tallie的Abigail曾经骄傲的、满足的生活是绿草地上与父亲嬉闹的Nellie而这一幕才让我意识到Tallie与Nellie名字有多相似她是她新的希望蔷薇之恋是她鲜活生命的astonishment and joy导演将4月26日到6月5日的时间单独留下直到Abigail终于触摸到Tallie冰冷的身躯时才让这段跳动缠绵的生命击打绝望悲痛的死亡感激Dyer
Probably Noah's best film, and definitely my favourite. Very nuanced portray of the complex, layered emotions of the two characters, with much warmth, sympathy, intelligence and gravity. It is very hard not to love Charlie and Nicole - both of them are their own stars. (重发另请大家去豆瓣电影页面给它的官方海报投票)